Frosthaven vs Gloomhaven: Which Has Better Solo Scenarios?

Quick answer

If you're playing Frosthaven, get Frosthaven: Solo Scenarios. If you're playing Gloomhaven 2nd Edition, get Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: Solo Scenarios. Both deliver class-specific solo missions and item rewards, but the packs are tied to their respective games, so the right choice depends on which campaign you're running.

Solo play in the Gloomhaven universe is less about playing the main campaign alone and more about mastering a single class through dedicated missions. Both Frosthaven and Gloomhaven 2nd Edition support this with official solo scenario packs, and each pack is designed to push one class to its limits.

The two packs look similar on the surface, but the details matter: scenario count, reward structure, and which game they plug into. Here's how they compare so you can pick the right one for your table.

What each solo scenario pack includes

Frosthaven: Solo Scenarios contains a 24-page scenario book with 17 all-new solo scenarios and a deck of 17 item cards, one reward for each completed mission. The scenarios are built to highlight each class's strengths and weaknesses, forcing you to learn the class deeply rather than rely on a single trick.

Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: Solo Scenarios contains a 24-page scenario book with 18 all-new solo scenarios and a deck of 18 item cards, one item per class rewarded for completing that class's mission. Like the Frosthaven pack, the design goal is to make you play each class masterfully.

• Both packs use a 24-page scenario book format.
• Frosthaven includes 17 scenarios and 17 item cards.
• Gloomhaven 2nd Edition includes 18 scenarios and 18 item cards.

Scenario count and reward structure

The one-scenario difference (17 vs 18) reflects the number of classes each pack supports. Frosthaven's pack covers its 17 characters, while the Gloomhaven 2nd Edition pack covers 18 classes. In both cases, the item card is a class-specific reward, so you only earn the item for the class you complete.

That structure means the packs are not interchangeable. A Frosthaven item card is meant for a Frosthaven class, and a Gloomhaven 2nd Edition item card is meant for a Gloomhaven 2nd Edition class. If you play both games, you'll want both packs to cover all classes.

• Each scenario is tied to a specific class.
• Item rewards are class-specific, not generic.
• Playing multiple classes means playing multiple scenarios.

Which pack fits your campaign

If your group is running a Frosthaven campaign, the Frosthaven pack is the natural fit. It uses Frosthaven classes and rewards, so you can slot the scenarios into your existing campaign without conversion. The same logic applies to Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: its pack is built for the 2nd Edition classes and their updated ability cards and mats.

If you're still on Gloomhaven 1st Edition, note that the Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: Class Upgrade Pack to 2nd Edition can bring the newest version of those mercenaries to your 1st Edition set or even to Jaws of the Lion and Frosthaven. That upgrade pack contains 18 class envelopes with updated ability cards, modifier decks, character mats, and tokens.

• Frosthaven pack: for Frosthaven classes only.
• Gloomhaven 2nd Edition pack: for Gloomhaven 2nd Edition classes only.
• Upgrade pack: bridges 1st Edition to 2nd Edition classes.

Solo play experience and difficulty

Both packs share the same design philosophy: scenarios that force you to understand a class's full toolkit. That means you can't brute-force them with a single powerful combo. You'll need to manage resources, positioning, and timing, which is exactly what makes them strong solo challenges.

Because the scenarios are class-specific, difficulty varies by class. Some classes will click immediately; others will take several attempts. That's intentional. The packs are not a difficulty setting, they're a mastery path.

• Expect to replay scenarios before earning the reward.
• Class choice matters more than player skill alone.
• Both packs reward system knowledge over luck.

Trade-offs at a glance

• Frosthaven: Solo Scenarios: 17 scenarios and 17 item cards, one per Frosthaven class. Choose this if you're actively playing Frosthaven and want to master its classes.
• Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: Solo Scenarios: 18 scenarios and 18 item cards, one per Gloomhaven 2nd Edition class. Choose this if you're playing Gloomhaven 2nd Edition and want full class coverage.
• Gloomhaven 1st Edition: Class Upgrade Pack to 2nd Edition: 18 class envelopes with updated cards, mats, and tokens. Choose this if you own 1st Edition and want the 2nd Edition class experience before buying solo scenarios.

Product facts

• Frosthaven: Solo Scenarios: A 24-page scenario book of 17 all-new solo scenarios and a deck of 17 item cards, rewards for completing each mission. Covers all 17 Frosthaven classes with a dedicated solo mission and a class-specific item reward.
• Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: Solo Scenarios: A 24-page scenario book of 18 all-new solo scenarios and a deck of 18 item cards, one item per class rewarded for completing their mission. Covers all 18 Gloomhaven 2nd Edition classes with a solo mission and a class-specific item reward.
• Gloomhaven (1st Edition): Class Upgrade Pack to 2nd Edition: Contains 18 Class Envelopes with updated ability cards, advance modifier deck, character mats, and character tokens. Lets 1st Edition owners bring 2nd Edition classes to their game, Jaws of the Lion, or Frosthaven.

Which should you buy?

Best for

• Frosthaven players who want solo missions for all 17 classes.
• Gloomhaven 2nd Edition players who want solo missions for all 18 classes.
• Players who own both games and want complete solo coverage.

Not for

• Players looking for a standalone game; both packs require the base game.
• Gloomhaven 1st Edition owners who haven't upgraded to 2nd Edition classes.
• Groups that only play multiplayer and never play solo.

The right solo scenario pack is the one that matches your campaign. Frosthaven players should pick up Frosthaven: Solo Scenarios, and Gloomhaven 2nd Edition players should pick up Gloomhaven 2nd Edition: Solo Scenarios. If you're on 1st Edition and want the 2nd Edition class experience, start with the Class Upgrade Pack, then add the solo scenarios.