Cragheart vs Bruiser vs Mindthief: Which Gloomhaven Pin to Collect
By Cephalofair - Epic Strategy Awaits | Published: 2026-10-17
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Cragheart, Bruiser, and Mindthief Collector's Pins from Gloomhaven. See size, price, and design differences to pick your favorite.
Quick answer
If you want the biggest, most visible pin, go with the Bruiser at 2.5 inches. For a detailed mid-size option, the Cragheart at 2 inches offers great value. The Mindthief is the smallest and most affordable, perfect for a subtle nod to your favorite class.
Size and presence on your bag or board
The most obvious difference between these three Gloomhaven Collector's Pins is their size. The Bruiser pin measures 2.5 inches, making it the largest of the trio. The Cragheart pin sits at 2 inches, while the Mindthief pin is the smallest at 1.5 inches. If you want your pin to stand out from across the room, the Bruiser is your pick. For a more balanced look that still catches the eye, the Cragheart is a solid middle ground. The Mindthief works well for a more understated collection or for fitting on a smaller display area.
Price and value per inch
All three pins are made from high quality synthetic hard enamel cast in black nickel, with rubber backing clasps for secure attachment. The Cragheart pin is priced at USD 7.09 (catalog comparison price USD 9.99). The Bruiser pin costs USD 6.49 (catalog comparison price USD 9.99), and the Mindthief pin is USD 5.99 (catalog comparison price USD 9.99). Considering the size difference, the Bruiser offers the most surface area for your dollar, while the Mindthief is the cheapest entry point into collecting individual class pins.
Design and character appeal
Each pin represents a distinct Gloomhaven starting class. The Cragheart is a ranged damage dealer with a rocky, earthy aesthetic. The Bruiser is a melee powerhouse with a straightforward, aggressive look. The Mindthief is a stealthy, mind-controlling rogue with a more intricate, smaller design. Your choice may ultimately come down to which class you enjoy playing most. All three share the same high-quality enamel and black nickel finish, so durability and feel are consistent across the line.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Bruiser: biggest presence, lowest price per inch: At 2.5 inches and USD 6.49, it offers the most visual impact for the lowest cost per square inch. The trade-off is that the design is simpler and may not appeal to fans of more intricate classes. Best for collectors who want a bold, affordable statement piece.
- Cragheart: balanced size and price: At 2 inches and USD 7.09, it strikes a middle ground between visibility and cost. The design is detailed but not as large as the Bruiser. Best for fans of the Cragheart class who want a well-proportioned pin.
- Mindthief: smallest and cheapest: At 1.5 inches and USD 5.99, it is the most affordable and discreet option. The trade-off is less detail and visibility compared to the larger pins. Best for budget-conscious collectors or those who prefer a subtle accessory.
Pin specs at a glance
- Cragheart Collectors Pin: 2" Collectors Pin by Cephalofair Games. High quality synthetic hard enamel. Cast in black nickel. Rubber Backing Clasps. The Cragheart is a mid-size pin that balances visibility with a reasonable price, making it a great all-rounder for fans of the class.
- Bruiser Collectors Pin: 2.5" Collectors Pin by Cephalofair Games. High quality synthetic hard enamel. Cast in black nickel. Rubber Backing Clasps. The Bruiser is the largest individual class pin available, giving you the most presence and detail for your collection.
- Mindthief Collectors Pin: 1.5" Collectors Pin by Cephalofair Games. High quality synthetic hard enamel. Cast in black nickel. Rubber Backing Clasps. The Mindthief is the smallest and most affordable pin, ideal for collectors on a budget or those who prefer a subtle accessory.
Which pin fits you?
Best for
- Collectors who want the largest, most visible pin: choose the Bruiser.
- Fans of the Cragheart class who want a balanced size and price: choose the Cragheart.
- Budget-minded collectors or those who prefer a small, subtle pin: choose the Mindthief.
Not for
- If you want the most detailed or intricate design, consider the Cragheart or Mindthief instead of the Bruiser.
- If you want a pin that stands out from a distance, the Mindthief may be too small for your needs.
